Friday, February 16, 2007

Adoptism

Last night I had my CASA training, Day 3. This training has been the best training I have ever attended for anything! It is eye-opening and fascinating to say the least. I am so excited to be a part of this organization. But, there have been some things said that have an anti-adoption tone to them and it has made me a little sad. Mainly that the notion still very much floats around that it is in the best interest of all children to be raised by their biological parents. Today, we went to the social security office to apply for Isaac's new card, since his birth certificate came! On the application it had you mark a category called "Natural or Adoptive Parent". What?! Are we not Isaac's natural parents? What are we....un-natural? I mentioned this to the lady who was processing the request for us and she told us that she had adopted her two children, who are now adults. And she said, "Wow, I thought we would be past this idea by now!" Not so. Before I went to bed, I finished a book called Adoption is a Family Affair! What Relatives and Friends Need to Know. I wanted to share some really interesting things that the book touched on:


"Racism: A belief that race is a primary determinant of human traits and capacities. A belief that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race. Prejudice or discrimination against someone on the basis of race.

Sexism: Prejudice or discrimination against someone on the basis of gender.

Adoptism: A belief that forming a family by birth is superior to forming a family by adoption. A belief that keeping a child with his/her biological parents is inherently better than placing a child for adoption...Prejudice or discrimination against members of the adoption triad."

As a society, we tend to understand the dangers of bias based on race, gender, or class. Adoptism is no different. Adoptism is just as damaging.

I wanted to share this because so far in our year as Isaac's Mommy and Daddy, we have not experienced racism. But we often experience adoptism. And it hurts us at a level that is hard to explain. Adoptism for us has sounded something like this (Yes, these are things people have said to us):

"Is he yours?"

"Are you sure that you tried hard enough/ waited long enough to have your own child?"

"Wow! You adopted? I thought I had heard you were pregnant?"

"That is so great, what ya'll have done. I could never do that!"

"We have always talked about adopting, after our second, third, fourth child."

"Are you sure you you are okay getting a black child? He/she will have enough issues just being adopted!"

"Where did you get him?"

"Oh! You couldn't have your own children?"

"We are so excited for him! Our child doesn't have any black friends!"

"If I had a baby, I could never give it away!"

"You know, once you adopt-you will get pregnant!"

"Why would anyone adopt overseas? There are enough babies here!"

"How much does it cost?" - Think about it, would I ask you how much your labor and delivery cost? No

"Is that your son? Yes he is my son. That's strange."

I share these things-not to be obnoxious-but to truly give you a little taste into the world of adoptism. One of the most common things we here when people hear him call us Mama and Daddy is, "Did you adopt him?" I feel like saying-"No, the genetic make-up of my husband and I just created an African American child. Isn't that the wildest thing?" Are these things mean-spirited? No-of course not! But it still hurts. Why? Because it sets us apart from the rest of the world. It marks us as different. Adoption is not a condition, it is a way that families are made like marriage and birth. I hope as we expand our family through adoption (yes, we want more!) that we will become better equiped to handle this kind of thing so that Isaac will know his family is special, not strange.

8 comments:

paigescrib. said...

I think that is is extremley rude when people say things like that and when you were filling that thing out how it said natural or adoptive parent. I guess they just want to know if you adopted him though, and putting adoptive parent dosn't make you un-natural!!! You ARE his mom and Billy IS his dad, and that doesn't make you un- natural!

Anonymous said...

Laurie,
I know I have been guilty of saying something similar to what you wrote. It makes me sad to know that you have to hear those comments so often, and they aren't going to stop anytime soon from the outside world. I do appreciate how you have been pro-active in teaching us - your friends and family, what is helpful and what is hurtful. I know we don't always get it right, but hope that I continue to have a teachable heart and that you continue to have a patient and understanding spirit. We love you guys so much and are blessed to be by your side.
PS> I just saw Monae's pics on your sight! So cute! Thank you so much for coming and keeping me company! It has become a tradition!
PSS. Can you try to resend that email we talked about?

Goggy Coffee said...

Brandi-
Thanks! I share these things because we can't always address every little grievance and I know the people who read this blog love us and want to support us. We don't always know "the other side" until someone helps us see! I know I have said plenty of tacky things to friends and family-and still do. I hope for the same grace and patience you do!
Love you!! Kiss those baby girls for me.

Laurie said...

Okay that was Laurie, not Billy! We were signed in on his account. Oops! :)

McGarity - St. John said...

this is what it looks like for us:
"whose is she?"
"she's ours."
"yes, but - which one of yours?"
awkward pause
"we're both adopting her."
"oh."

because we're two moms, people assume one of us gave birth to her - which one, for some reason, is the important thing for them to know. it feels like, "which one of you is her REAL mom." what?!

i'm happy to say, though, that we've gotten positive responses from most people. hopefully, over time, the questions will become easier to answer. i think people are curious and they don't think about the way they phrase questions.

we're glad you guys are back on-line. isaac's valentine picture is 100% adorable!

have a blessed day :)

Laurie said...

Thanks for sharing, Lori and Holly!
Don't ya'll finalize Shae's adoption sometime this month?

McGarity - St. John said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
McGarity - St. John said...

yes, this friday!! we couldn't be more excited. she's 6 months old today.. we didn't waste any time setting the court date! :)

we're actually finalizing in san antonio. we're spending thursday night on the riverwalk and then we'll legally be her parents by noon friday.